Environmental Considerations
Always trying to aim for being environmentally thoughtful, I’m currently trying to avoid using any brushes in my studio, so that I don’t contaminate the water system with unnecessary plastic waste. When I do use brushes and acrylic paint, I wash them in a small amount of water that I transfer to a bucket that eventually evaporates. The amount that goes down the drain during their final soapy wash is a tiny fraction of what it used to be when I washed brushes under a running tap.
I am also using Indian ink when painting outdoors, rather than acrylic paint or acrylic ink, again aiming to reduce any plastic going into the environment – please see the extract below comparing the environmental impact of different inks.
India ink is generally better for the environment than acrylic ink because it is typically made from natural, biodegradable ingredients (carbon black pigment and water), while acrylic ink contains non-biodegradable, petroleum-derived plastic polymers that contribute to microplastic water pollution.
India Ink
- Composition: Traditional black India ink is primarily composed of carbon black pigment (soot) suspended in water, often with a natural binder like shellac (a natural resin from the lac beetle) or gelatin to make it water-resistant.
- Environmental Impact:
- Biodegradability: The core components, carbon black and water, are natural and highly biodegradable. Shellac is also a natural, renewable, and biodegradable biopolymer.
- Microplastics: It does not contain synthetic polymers, so it does not release liquid plastic microparticles when rinsed down the drain.
- Toxicity: While the raw ingredients for carbon black can have environmental impacts during production (traditional methods often use fossil fuels, though sustainable alternatives like those made from air pollution or wood waste exist), the final ink product is generally considered non-toxic and safe for school use in its water-based form.
Acrylic Ink
- Composition: Acrylic inks are essentially very fluid acrylic paints, consisting of pigments suspended in an acrylic resin binder or polymer emulsion. The resins are derived from petroleum.
- Environmental Impact:
- Microplastics: The primary environmental concern is the presence of plastic polymers. When brushes or tools are washed, these minute plastic particles enter the water system and contribute to the growing problem of microplastic pollution in oceans and even drinking water.
- Non-biodegradable: Acrylic resins are not biodegradable, meaning they persist in the environment and landfills for long periods.
- VOCs: While generally low-VOC (volatile organic compounds) compared to traditional oil-based paints, the production of the acrylic resins and associated solvents can have an environmental footprint.
Conclusion
For environmentally conscious artists, traditional India ink represents a more eco-friendly choice due to its natural, biodegradable composition and the absence of persistent microplastics. Proper disposal of any art material rinse water is always recommended to minimize environmental impact, regardless of the ink type.
